What is a Fiduciary Advisor? Real-Life Examples Demonstrate the Difference


Most people assume that anyone who gives financial advice is legally required to put your interests first. They aren't. Unless you are working with a fiduciary, your financial advisor may be held only to a standard of "suitability," meaning the product they sell you simply must be appropriate, not best. In some cases, they can earn more by steering you toward one option over another.
A fiduciary financial advisor has a legal duty to act in the client's best interest, taking into account the client’s specific circumstances and objectives. Advisors cannot put their interests ahead of the client’s.
How Does a Financial Advisor Become a Fiduciary?
One common misconception is that an advisor earns a special “fiduciary certification.” That's not generally how it works.
A financial advisor becomes a fiduciary mainly through how they're registered: advisors who register with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) or their state as investment advisers (or work as representatives of a firm registered as an investment advisor) are legally bound to act in their clients' best interest. Advisors may also earn a credential such as Certified Financial Planner (CFP), which requires a fiduciary commitment, or they may agree to serve as trustee for an estate, which carries fiduciary responsibilities. It is possible for an advisor to be a fiduciary for some services but not others.
It can be confusing, so clients should always ask if the fiduciary obligation applies to their entire relationship and all investments. Be sure to ask how the advisor and firm are compensated and review the firm’s disclosures before hiring a new advisor.
What Does a Fiduciary Financial Advisor Actually Do?
A fee-only fiduciary advisor doesn't earn commissions on products such as whole life insurance or annuities. Rather, a fiduciary advisor starts by learning about a client’s financial goals and situation and then creating a plan to try to realize those goals while considering the client’s personal circumstances and tolerance for risk.
When a new client comes to us, we don't assume that everything they already own needs to be replaced. But we also don't assume that everything they've been doing is still appropriate.
We start by asking:
What does the client own?
Why do they own it?
Does it still serve a useful purpose?
What are the consequences of changing investments?
Thoughtful questioning and review can uncover some overlooked opportunities. One client came to us with a whole life policy that had been overlooked. We discovered it during our in-depth onboarding discussions, reviewed the surrender and tax implications, and incorporated the decision into the client’s broader financial plan.
Another client came to us with an annuity that had been in place for years without much attention. We learned about it during a tax-planning conversation and asked the client to obtain a current statement so we could evaluate whether it still served a useful purpose in the client's overall plan.
Frequently, a client comes to us holding high-cost actively managed funds through a full-service brokerage relationship. Would that client be better served by a low-cost index fund? Our job as fiduciary advisors is to evaluate the options and make recommendations that we feel will serve that client best.
Whether a client’s portfolio holds whole life insurance and annuities or crypto and private equity, a fiduciary advisor will consider the investments in context. Do they make sense for the client in light of that client’s goals, risk tolerance, portfolio and life circumstances?
What Happens When a Recommendation Conflicts with a Client Preference?
Being a fiduciary doesn't mean agreeing with everything a client wants to do. Sometimes the most valuable advice is to provide another viewpoint so a decision is made thoughtfully.
For example, one client sent us a detailed defense of an existing financial product, explaining why they believed keeping it made sense. They did a great analysis, but we didn’t simply agree. Instead, we brought the discussion back to the client's actual goals. The product might work, but only if it genuinely supported the retirement lifestyle the client had described. A theoretical benefit wasn't enough if the strategy didn't fit the client's broader financial plan.
A good fiduciary advisor will help a client make informed decisions and not simply tell them what they want to hear. The advisor’s role is to provide the analysis, perspective and experience necessary to craft a well-considered plan to realize financial goals.
Questions to Ask Before Hiring a Fiduciary Advisor
Many financial professionals who aren't subject to a broad fiduciary obligation provide valuable advice and act ethically. But advisors who are not specifically fiduciaries may operate under different regulatory standards. They may be permitted to encourage clients to purchase investment products that earn a commission, regardless of whether those products are the best fit for the client.
If you are looking for an advisor, consider asking:
Are you a fiduciary?
When does your fiduciary obligation apply?
Is your firm a Registered Investment Advisor (RIA)?
How are you and your firm compensated?
Do you receive commissions for recommending financial products?
Will you review investments, insurance and annuities I already own?
How do you incorporate taxes into your recommendations?
How do you identify and manage conflicts of interest?
What happens if you think I'm making a financial decision that isn't in my best interest?
Do you provide ongoing financial planning or primarily investment management?
Finding a Fiduciary
A fiduciary financial advisor may be right for you if:
You want comprehensive financial planning, not just investment management but also retirement income, taxes, Social Security, estate planning, insurance, charitable giving, etc.
You are approaching or living in retirement. Decisions about when to claim Social Security, which accounts to draw from, tax-efficient withdrawals and managing market risk can have a much bigger impact than simply choosing investments.
You have significant assets or multiple types of accounts and don't want to coordinate everything yourself.
You want someone to provide an objective second opinion before making major financial decisions.
You don't enjoy managing investments or monitoring your financial plan yourself.
You want an advisor whose obligation is to put your interests ahead of their own. SEC-registered investment advisers are required to act in their clients' best interests, although you should still examine their conflicts and compensation arrangements.
The National Association of Personal Financial Advisors (NAPFA) offers a free tool to locate fee-only fiduciary financial advisors in your location. Visit napfa.org to begin your search.
As a fee-only fiduciary financial advisor, Gold Medal Waters serves clients across the country from our home base in Colorado. If you need financial advice and planning, book a free, initial consultation to learn how Gold Medal Waters can help.
Disclosure: Advisory Services are offered through Gold Medal Waters, a Registered Investment Advisor. This post and material presented are for informational and illustrative purposes only, and do not constitute investment advice and is not intended as an endorsement of any specific investment. As such, this material is not client-specific, we adjust in individual portfolios based on each client's financial plan, income needs, risk tolerance and total asset allocation. Interactive checklists are made available to you as self-help tools for your independent use and are not intended to provide investment advice. While Gold Medal Waters believes information derived from third-party sources to be accurate and reliable, we do not claim or have responsibility for its completeness, accuracy, or reliability about your individual circumstances. Investors should carefully consider the investment objectives, risks, charges, and expenses associated with any investment. The information discussed is not intended to render tax or legal advice. Be sure to first consult with a qualified financial adviser and/or tax professional before implementing any strategy discussed herein. Investing involves risk including the potential loss of principal, and unless otherwise stated, are not guaranteed. Past performance does not guarantee future results. No investment strategy can guarantee a profit or protect against loss in periods of declining values. Geopolitical events are unpredictable and can lead to significant market liquidity issues and volatility that may not be captured in historical models. Consult your financial professional before making any investment decision.





Comments